Shut your mouth an Here comes the pain had THE BEST season mode ever, and the best selection on create a superstar/diva. The only issue I had with the game was that the graphics were super bad for the created superstars.
So, the best game there is will have to be SVR 2006. I have no idea why people voted for a game that hasn't even come out yet. xD
2007 had a great storyline as well, but a lot of the options you had in 07 were sorta limited. 08 was really dissapointing. Everything about it sucked, except for the graphics. 2009, was a tad bit better since they slightly repaired the create a wrestler dude, but the season mode still sucked. 2010 took 5495 steps back, and I sold that game the week after I bought it. That was how bad I thought that game was. 2011.. Heh, not going to bother. I'm fine as long as my HCTP does not mess up.