I like the idea and concept of GutCheck but I think they need to go back to where a they bring someone in to face someone already on the roster. I think this would allow for a more interesting concept and more interesting matches as you can have guys like Kurt Angle, Austin Aries, Samoa Joe, Christopher Daniels, Bobby Roode, etc carry the matches that may not be as interesting with 2 indy guys that may end up clashing. Also, you could have a TNA guy lose here and there to help build a potential future storyline. For example, Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards are free agents as of August 1st. I would love to see TNA bring these 2 in for a Gut Check match against Christopher Daniels and Kazarian and have the American Wolves beat Daniels and Kazarian. The American Wolves are then giving a contract and a feud between them and Bad Influence begins.
Also, I think the judges need to change. I have no interest whatsoever in listening to Bruce Prichard (Brother Love), Al Snow and Danny Davis. All are too old and boring and personally I think TNA needs to can Prichard and Snow and cut ties from OVW and Davis but that's just my opinion. Anyways, back on topic, I think they should use current stars like Kurt Angle, Austin Aries, Bobby Roode, Christopher Daniels and/or Kazarian... or bring in former TNA stars that the fans may be more interested in like Jeff Jarrett, Raven and Jerry Lynn.