I think we should give the guy a break! I mean come on, Abyss has been out of action for almost a year, no one has seen him! Meanwhile his brother Joseph Park has been trying to figure out what is going on, and train for in-ring action.....oh...wait, nevermind, i see what is going on here.
But on a serious note, the return in my mind was fine. Ya, he almost tripped, almost didn't get Kennedy (edit: Anderson) high enough, BHS was a little sloppy, but for a return, it worked well, sets the stage for the monster to take revenge on A&8s for hurting Joseph blah blah blah. All we need now is a bag full of tacks.
The biggest problem is that Abyss is TNA's Kane, and so that is our measuring stick, which is almost unfair.