In ring action that involves more than punch, punch, kick, Irish whip, move A, Cover... Repeat with move B, then with move C.
A match with time to get me invested in the action in the ring, not just how much Wrestler X doesn't like Wrestler Y.
A storyline that makes sense and has a decent build. 3 months is usually a minimum as there are plenty of other wrestlers on their rosters to fill in the voids where both wrestlers aren't competing against each other.
Eric Young comedy, Damien Sandow's arrogance, Dirty Heels (Aries/Roode) vs. Bad Influence (minus the Hernandez/Chavo being injected into the feud), Almost any card that has the DragonGate or NJPW names on them, Crowds that are into the experience (even if they aren't into the action in the ring), back and forth matches, Dolph Ziggler's build before they gave him a "run" with the WHC, impressive moves (one of the reasons why I have grown to appreciate Zema Ion; some of his transitions in the 3-way matches have been awesome), James Storm T-Shirts (Save Water; Drink Beer and Beer Hunter), Evan Bourne's Shooting Star Press (Sorry Kidman), Ricardo Rodriguez and Joseph Park facial expressions... Hell, there is a lot to be loved when you appreciate the art and look past what the interwebs tell you is good or not.