Sooooooo, we'd get a wrestler that's at best a John Cena level wrestler? Let's be honest, Rock was not the best in-ring performer. He went through his set of moves, then his match was over. He's the same way on the mic. He goes through his mic set and then it's over. Given his mic skills are entertaining. Why would bringing a guy back that isn't going to be there day in and day out going to bring people back? If you give Rock the strap, you might as well give it to Stone Cold or Undertaker. They are likely to wrestle just as many matches as the Rock and make just as many appearances.