Was SmackDown not live in the UK too? I'm pretty sure it was, which makes me wonder why the author has *spoiler* in the title?
Anyway to the point, it did seem like Show botched his elimination. Maybe it was just that it seemed to the viewer like he might hold on, when in fact he was just meant to fall straight out.
The bigger botch I thought was the ending to Show vs Kane. Show appeared to injure his shoulder spearing Kane onto the chair, then Kane fumbled around with the chair and pretty much, on camera, just placed the chair in the middle of the ring so Show could Slam him onto it. He then shook his arm a bit like Orton did when he separated his shoulder against Edge, then clambered out of the ring selling the injury, then no-sold the injury up the ramp. It was all very confusing.