Originally Posted by Tommy Thunder
No Carroll just doesn't work well with Liverpools tactics.
He worked so well at Newcastle because the same reason Ba scores so many for Newcastle.
A bit like Berbatov not being a great as he was at Spurs. But that's mainly because Spurs strikers are closer to the goal then United players are on counter attacks.
Besides choosing 1 player crap form doesn't make Toms opinion less correct of Seria A being dull.
Although I 100% agree with you that Maldini has been 1 of the best defenders over many years and is a prime example of why premier league watchers shouldn't judge players on age or spend. It annoys me when I suggest players for my friend on FIFA who to buy and he cancels them out cause that player is 34. Still got a few good years left in him!!!