View RSS Feed

Domkin

The Value of a Title

Rate this Entry
Hi all,

I wanted to steer slightly away from the usual Mania build up discussions this week and pose the question - just what is a title worth these days?


There has been some commentary on the lack of focus on titles in this years Wrestlemania. The SD match is way down the pecking order, the Punk/Jericho match is more about the ’Best in the World’ moniker, no tag team title match, no divas title match (no loss there though) and no US title match. So is it the case that holding a title doesn’t mean as much as it used to?

Let’s start by comparing the title reigns of the wrestling stars of yester year compared to modern day Superstars

Now I could list stats all day but here’s a few examples for you (I have included both the World and WWE Championship in these stats)

Rock – 7
Stone Cold – 6
Hogan – 6
Taker – 6
Bret Hart – 5
HBK – 4
Flair – 2 (Yes the 16 time champion only won 2 of them with the WWE)

And let’s compare that to the current and recent main eventers over the past few years

Triple H - 13
Cena – 12
Edge - 11
Orton - 9
Batista – 6
CM Punk – 5

I admit there’s a 101 different arguments that can be put forward like HBK was out for 4 years, if Flair hadn’t moved to WCW, and of course the what if Stone Cold and The Rock had continued in WWE but the facts are clear that the WWE are more liberal with the main titles than they were in previous eras. Granted Trips is coming to the end of his run so maybe one more if he’s lucky but the likes of Cena and Orton if they remain healthy have more than a decade left so we could be talking title counts in their 20’s. Again I pose the question, does this devalue the title?

Viewing styles could be to blame. The business is less reluctant to give someone a long run with a title as it generates such criticism and we long for continual shake ups to the status quo. Look at the lengthy runs by Cena, HHH and The Wrestling God himself JBL, all were heavily condemned by the IWC for holding back talent and not giving other people a chance to shine. On the flip side when the likes of Del Rio, Miz and Bryan get a title the same people scream for them to lose it pronto.

To give a title reign kudos, it has to have some longevity to it in fact at the moment of the 4 main WWE titles only the US title is being poorly booked at the moment. Both RAW and SD champions have held the titles for getting on for 4 months now which is a good healthy run and I actually expect both to retain at Mania. The real ‘title winner’ at the moment is Cody Rhodes. Being allowed to retain the title since August last year has enabled him to grow in stature and has brought respect and value back to the IC title. Making a champion hard to beat not only elevates the holder but also the competitor who finally beats them for the title.

So my conclusion is that a title is worth everything it used to be, it’s still a reward for had work and a recognition of ability to represent and promote the business positively But exciting and headline stealing as title changes may be, the longer the reign the bigger the final payoff for both the business and the wrestler.

As usual, all comments counter opinions and abuse welcome.

Also feel free to follow me on Twitter @dmayerl

Submit "The Value of a Title" to Digg Submit "The Value of a Title" to del.icio.us Submit "The Value of a Title" to StumbleUpon Submit "The Value of a Title" to Google

Comments

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
  1. DK Wrestling Savior's Avatar
    Titles have been devalued. I fully agree. I'm really hoping for someone with a really long title run, but not a Bobby Roode or Daniel Bryan type where they weasel their way out of every match. But legit title holder where it becomes intriguing to find out who, if anyone, can dethrone the champ. Much like Hogan in the 80's.
  2. wrestlingfan66513's Avatar
    Aries run is my favorite right now. He cheats his way out sometimes but the last two PPV title defenses have been clean so he is mixing it up. Rhodes doesn't defend his title much and he held it for a long time.
  3. Mikeyboy7777777's Avatar
    the only thing i disagree with is the tag titles please put the usos in a feud with epico & primo don't let kofi and his partner of the month become champs or beat the champs again.
    let them feud with ziggler & swagger.
    but insert the usos in a feud with epico & primo they can have great matches maybe insert tamina? let them have a couple of title wins over each other perhaps let epico & primo win the titles back?
  4. akbar's Avatar
    as good edge was as a wrestler, him winning 11 times within like 5 years is a joke, same for ortan...good blog
  5. little.Jimmy's Avatar
    o this makes title more becaue eit shows it is harder it keep the title today
  6. TheGreatOne's Avatar
    I hate the idea of hearing guys winning so many world titles......

    All the stupid things they do with the championship now like Edge losing a world title and leaving with the WWE title the same night. Only to have Cena win it back at Wrestlemania so Edge can win it back at backlash? Jeff wins world title at Extreme Rules. Punk cashes in MITB and wins the world title. Faces Jeff at the next ppv like Night of Champions and loses the belt. Faces him at Summerslam and win it back. Why not just have Cena defend vs Big Show and Edge at Mania rather than have him lose it? Why not have Edge get his rematch vs Punk at the next ppv so you won't have to do those title changes like that. Do a triple threat on the next ppv. Something other than goofy matches tossing the title back and forth.
  7. UnstoppableThombo's Avatar
    Good blog, but gotta say I disagree with you about Cody Rhodes bringing "value" back to the IC title. I'd agree with statement if he'd defended it at more ppv's, and well just more in general. Sorry, but it's pretty obvious its no longer the workhorse's title as Bret and HBK have referred to it as back in the 90's. Case and point, if Cody had defended it against Randy Orton when they had their ppv match last year and retained, then yes there would be more value to the title, but apparently Orton's too big a draw for the IC title nowadays, yet Jericho and Mysterio weren't a few years ago.
    Updated 03-21-2012 at 12:46 PM by UnstoppableThombo
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

© 2011 eWrestlingNews, All Rights Reserved.